Visit the Abbey of the Arts online retreat platform to access your programs:

Abbey Bookshelf: An Altar in the World (on belief and practice)

“Welcome to your own priesthood,
practiced at the altar of your own life.” (xvii)

“Christianity ‘is not a set of beliefs or doctrines one believes in order to be a Christian, but rather Christianity is to have one’s body shaped, one’s habits determined, in such a way that the worship of God is unavoidable.’ (quote from Stanley Hauerwas) In our embodied life together, the words of our doctrines take on flesh.  If one of our orthodox beliefs has no corporeal value, if we cannot come up with a single consequence it has for our embodied life together, then there is good reason to ask why we should bother with it at all.” (44-45)

An Altar in the World: A Geography of Faith by Barbara Brown Taylor

“I say that religion isn’t about believing things. It’s ethical alchemy. It’s about behaving in a way that changes you, that gives you intimations of holiness and sacredness.”

Karen Armstrong

I began reflecting on Taylor’s beautiful book a few weeks ago. For many months now I have come to a place in my spiritual life where belief is far less important than practice.  In the world around us, we are inundated with messages rooted in a battle over beliefs, but very little of which spills over into how we actually treat one another.

Karen Armstrong writes that belief is only a very recent religious emphasis, emerging in the western world in the 17th century, when the definition of belief became much narrower in focus to mean an intellectual assent.  But, she goes on to say, religion is not about belief but about how we behave. “Doctrine are to be understood as summons to action. You only understand them when you put them into practice. Pride of place is given to compassion. When we get rid of ego we grow closer to the divine. Any belief that leads to hatred of others is illegitimate.”

For me, orthopraxis (right practice) has always been more important than orthodoxy (right belief).  In an interview with Raimundo Pannikar I recently read, a man who was raised by a Catholic mother and Hindu father, considers himself fully both. “How is that possible?” he asks. “By living religion as an experience rather than as an ideology,” Pannikar responds.

One of the many reasons I love monastic spirituality and am a Benedictine Oblate is I find in this path a call to practice hospitality, humility, contemplative ways of being, a movement toward radical simplicity, and service shaped by love. These are not abstract concepts, but ideas which become real only when enfleshed. My spiritual director said to me the other day, “everything we do is a form of self-narration.”  I have been contemplating this phrase, wondering what story my life and practice tells about me.  Am I witness to compassion?  Does my life lay bare an authentic journey toward love?  Is my belief in the enlivening and transforming power of creativity expressed in how I perform the daily tasks of my day? Do I embody the things I say I value most?

What is the story your life tells about what you consider to be most vital in the world?  Has your body been shaped by what you believe to be true, so that every movement, every word transforms you?

© Christine Valters Paintner at Abbey of the Arts:
Transformative Living through Contemplative & Expressive Arts

* There is still time to register for the Honoring Our Ancestors Art & Movement Retreat October 29-November 1, 2009 on the beautiful Hood Canal. *

Become a fan of the Abbey on Facebook, follow this blog on Facebook, friend me on Facebook or follow me on Twitter

You might also enjoy

Monk in the World Guest Post: Kate Kennington Steer

I am delighted to share another beautiful submission to our Monk in the World guest post series from the community. Read on for Kate Kennington Steer’s reflection Heart of Stone. I arrived at February 2023 in a post-viral fatigue fug, feeling beset by depression, with

Read More »

Soul of a Pilgrim Video Podcast Day 2

Blessing for Packing Lightly*Winnowing God, you ask us to release, let go, surrender, and yield all that we canin service of making space for what is most essential. The more we set aside that which burdens us and takes up too much spacethe more room

Read More »

Monk in the World Guest Post: Mary Camille Thomas

I am delighted to share another beautiful submission to our Monk in the World guest post series from the community. Read on for Mary Camille Thomas’s reflection Sitting in Paradise. “Sit in your cell as in paradise,” St. Romuald says in his brief rule for

Read More »

8 Responses

  1. Do you believe that there are other sacred words besides the Bible that we should follow? Do you believe that there is more than one way to God the Father except through the Son, Jesus Christ?

  2. I actually believe that God is big enough to offer multiple sacred words and paths to people. It is not a watering down but a mutual enrichment. We can not possibly contain the vast beauty and complexity of God with our own minds. My issue here is, in part, that so often those who proclaim to follow God’s Word are some of the least compassionate and welcoming people I know. When Word becomes prized over action, and righteousness over love, the true meaning of religion has become distorted.

  3. What often happens when orthodoxy is left behind is a watered down version of the Word. We need both God’s Word AND action. Can we not have both? We must have both to be pleasing to our Lord. If He didn’t care about the sacredness of his Word, why give it to us?

  4. kigen, yes indeed, we much approach each other with humility and care.

    Thanks for the link Maureen. Karen Armstrong also has a new book out – The Case for God.

    debbie, I fully support your right to believe as you do, but your comment actually reflects what I was suggesting is not a helpful approach – by insisting on orthodoxy rather than seeing where our actions extend care out to the world and embracing the compassion of those who believe differently than we do.

  5. Remember that James said, “I will show you my faith by what I do.” Our faith and belief in God should produce our good works. Any other works done for any other reason or in any other name aren’t good in God’s sight. They’re “bad good works” as Dr. John Gerstner called them.

    And to Kigen, true peace will only come about when Christ’s enemies are made his footstool. I think it’s a good thing to seek peace but not at the cost of the purity of Holy Scripture. Christianity cannot be practiced alongside any other religion. God makes that pretty plain to the ancient Hebrews who tried it.

  6. I just listened to Karen Armstrong’s Ted Talk. She is a wonderful speaker and scholar. What she has to say is so vital. That she believes such a Charter is possible fills my heart with hope.

    I used a bit of Armstrong’s quote as the Thought for the Day on my blog and linked from my blog to yours.

  7. Gandhi carried both the Bible and the Bhagavagita with him whereever he went. He believed, as many Christians peacemakers do also, that through interfaith communication peace can be won